If there’s one makeup product I can’t stop testing, it’s brow gel.

With thick, stubborn brow hairs, finding formulas that actually hold everything in place is a challenge. I’ve tried a lot, and these are the ones that have earned a spot in my current collection. Below are my honest ratings and how each one performs for me.

1. REFY Brow Sculpt Gel (10/10)

This one is definitely polarizing, but for me? Absolute perfection. When I want my brows to look flawless all day — especially for a full face or a night out — this is what I reach for. My brows stay lifted, structured, and polished without flaking or feeling crunchy.

2. ICONIC London Tint & Texture Brow Gel – Chocolate Brown (4/10))

This used to be a regular in my routine, but over time it just stopped delivering. While the tint is nice, the hold simply isn’t strong enough for my brows. After a short while, my hairs start moving on their own, which completely defeats the purpose.

3. NYX The Brow Glue – Dark Brown (10/10))

This is proof that drugstore products can seriously compete with high-end. I love using this on low-effort makeup days when I don’t want to fill in my brows. The tint adds instant fullness, and the hold is impressive — my brow hairs stay locked in place for hours.

4. e.l.f. Clear Brow & Lash Mascara (8/10))

This is my go-to for ultra-minimal makeup days. When I’m just wearing mascara and lip balm, this adds that extra touch of polish without feeling heavy. The formula is lightweight but still keeps my brows neat and in place.

Brow gels are not one-size-fits-all, especially if you have thick or stubborn brow hairs. While some formulas didn’t work for me, others completely exceeded expectations. Whether you want full glam hold or a soft, natural finish, there’s something here for every makeup mood.